The Philadelphia Phillies mascot is the defendant in a lawsuit stemming from a fan’s injuries at a minor league baseball game. Plaintiff’s lawsuit alleges that the “Phillie Phanatic” climbed on top of her during a game in 2008 which causing Plaintiff arthritis to get worse which, Plaintiff believes, caused her to need a knee replacement.
Exacerbation of prior arthritis claims are incredibly tough because it so hard for the doctors to really state strong opinions as to whether a trauma accident caused her injuries to worsen. I also imagine there are liability problems. In these kind of case, I always fear the lawsuit is filed in part because it is a case against the Phille Phanatic and that sounds a little interesting so let’s bring a case we otherwise would not. Again, I have no facts to support this but it does make you wonder when you hear cases with these kinds of facts.